Wednesday, October 4, 2017

High Point Municipal Primaries

Mayor

Challengers: Bruce Davis, Jim Davis, Jay Wagner

The city will elect its third new mayor after Becky Smothers was in office for 16 of 20 years on and off from 1992 to 2012.

The contest seems to be between the last two candidates as Jim Davis and Wagner have traded barbs against each other over a range of issues, and the mudslinging did not end at last night's forum either.

At first, I was going to go with Bruce Davis but then, I had reservations as to whether the county commissioner turned CVB head would once again have his eyes set on higher office--after all, he ran unsuccessfully for State Senate twice this decade and for Congress the last two national cycles--once the mess with the General Assembly's drawing of state and congressional lines is finally settled. However, I listened to what he said at the forum and how he laid out everything related to the proposed stadium, and it made more sense than the way the current mayor and various High Point leaders conducted themselves with the county commissioners. As a result, I have switched back from Wagner to Bruce Davis for mayor since Wagner sided with Bill Bencini and Company's rapid fire push to get the stadium built by 2019 which led to the pushback from the county commissioners.

Ward 4

Challengers: Jim Bronnert, Wesley Hudson, Jody Kearns

The three men are running to succeed Wagner. Bronnert lost to Wagner three years ago. Hudson recently ran for office in Winston-Salem before moving to High Point. Kearns's main motivation for running seems to be the fact that he has a grudge against Wagner.

Ward 5

Challengers: Victor Jones, Deric Stubbs, Sr., Chris Whitley

These three are running to replace Jim Davis. Jones was the only one to appear at last evening's forum. I was willing to give Stubbs a chance and still might if he advances but the no-show was not a good look. As for Whitley, I hold him just as accountable for High Point's status as the hungriest city in America as I do former mayor Smothers since both were in and out of City Council throughout the '90s and '00s as the older parts of the city broke down.

At-Large

Incumbent: Cynthia Davis
Challengers: Mary Lou Andrews Blakeney, Daniel Gardner, Michael Holmes, Britt Moore, Sarah Jane Otte, Don Scarbrough

Cynthia Davis is the most conservative of the current council and the only one who voted against the stadium.

Moore wants his seat back after narrowly losing it to Latimer Alexander IV. He joined Wagner in wanting to keep the City Project back in the spring of 2014 but joined what was left of City Council to kill the plan to reduce part of North Main Street from five lanes to two as a part of a street diet right before the election.

Blakeney also wants to return to the council. She won the second seat in a wave election in 2008 only to lose it to Moore in another wave election two years later.

Scarborough was a part of High Point University's rapid growth, which is part gift and part curse. On one hand, the university's growth has acted as a buffer in keeping the older east central part of the city from decaying. On the other hand, the university has helped to perpetuate the balkanization of the city into three distinct fiefdoms--the university area, the newer parts in the extreme northern part of the city and the older parts in the rest of the city. Also, I still bear a grudge over how the school handled the MLK street renaming controversy in early 2015.

While I do agree with Gardner (among others) that the stadium project should have been placed on the ballot as a referendum, most of his ideology doesn't line up with mine.

In the end, I'll go with Holmes and Otte in addition to Blakeney.

Sunday, September 24, 2017

Greensboro Mayor

Incumbent: Nancy Vaughan
Challengers: John Brown, Dianne Moffett

Vaughan is the first person since Keith Holliday to be reelected. She campaigned to be more transparent four years ago than her predecessor but has been less so. Like most mayors, she has ignored the city's east side. While there are members of the creative community who have developed a rapport with her, Vaughan's commitment to the Tanger PAC and the city's old guard seriously compromises her position as a friend of the arts.

Her first opponent, Brown, says that he's a supporter of the arts but unlike ex-mayor Bill Knight, I've never seen him at any of the local arts events. He might frequent the same art events as the city's 1% but none of the really groundbreaking or iconoclastic stuff. Then, there's this (and four more like it).

The other challenger, Moffett, is a popular pastor in East Greensboro. The catch is that her downtown apartment isn't her primary residence.

The underlying premise is that Vaughan is unpopular but not unpopular enough for a unifying opponent to dethrone her. Absent a major political earthquake, one of the challengers will be eliminated on October 10. Conservatives in West Greensboro are unlikely to support Moffett if Brown is eliminated and could sit out the mayor's race like they did in '13 and '15. Meanwhile, blacks in East Greensboro are just as unlikely to support Brown if Moffett is eliminated and could either skip the mayoral selection or very reluctantly support Vaughan.

As a result, I am encouraging the creative community to skip this race in the primary and the primary only.

Greensboro City Council At-Large

Incumbents: Marikay Abuzuaiter, Mike Barber, Yvonne Johnson
Challengers: Irving David Allen, M.A. Bakie, T. Dianne Bellamy-Small, Jodi Bennett-Bradshaw, Tijuana Hayes, Sylvine Hill, James Ingram, Dan Jackson, Michelle Kennedy, Andy Nelson, Lindy Perry-Garnette, Dave Wils

There are four challengers for every incumbent--that alone should say something about how fed up people really are with Greensboro's business as usual government. 2015 was the first time since the current 5-3-1 system was implemented in 1983 that there were no primaries for the at-large seats as there were only three challengers

Obviously, it would be a horrible outcome if all three incumbents prevail in November. However, there's another outcome that would be arguably worse: the city's political clans co-opting the anti-incumbent sentiment by deeming one of the incumbents expendable (likely Abuzuaiter or Barber) and using an outsider to further their corporatist ends.

Rather than break down every single candidate running in this race, I have decided to place the 15 candidates into five tiers and provide explanations for some candidates. The first tier will be my official endorsements, the second tier represents candidates I would like to see advance to the general election, and the last one automatically includes the three incumbents.

Tier 1: Allen, Hill, Kennedy
Tier 2: Wils, Perry-Garnette, Hayes
Tier 3: Bennett-Bradshaw, Bakie, Nelson
Tier 4: Ingram, Jackson, Bellamy-Small
Tier 5: Johnson, Abuzuaiter, Barber

Allen: He was a panelist at Elsewhere's election night party last year and is a cool guy.

Bellamy-Small: She needs to figure out whether she wants to represent the county's schoolchildren or return to the Melvin Municipal Building.

Bennett-Bradshaw: I wanted to support her but her platform is very vague despite her saying all of the right things.

Ingram: He's backed by the some of the very state legislators responsible for dragging the state's reputation through the mud.

Jackson: In the mold of Wilkins? No thanks!

Greensboro District 5

Incumbent: Tony Wilkins
Challengers: Sal Leone, Tanner Lucas, Tammi Thurm

Wilkins was the first one of the three City Councilmen to be appointed--except in his case he had to overcome a hostile effort by then-Mayor Robbie Perkins to prevent him from being appointed after Trudy Wade got elected to the State Senate in 2012.

The incumbent is the biggest obstacle to the arts community hands down. First, he wrote a Facebook post in 2013 that inaccurately described a routine done by Foxy Moxy at the inaugural East-West BBQ Fest. The truth was that the performance was at a tent that was clearly marked as "adults only."

The second incident happened at the beginning of this year when he called the Fire Department on Geeksboro before the Idiot Box held "A Trump Roast." It's clear to me that the county's GOP bigwigs didn't appreciate the comedy club poking fun at the most humorless president in decades and needed to slow the momentum of the Idiot Box and Geeksboro.

Leone advanced to the primary election four years ago. His anti-East Greensboro slam won't win him any friends on that side of town given that this is his fourth run for Greensboro office (his last one was the anticlimactic '15 mayoral race).

Lucas has some good ideas but the district skews older demographically, so I'm giving the edge to Thurm.

Greensboro District 4

Incumbent: Nancy Hoffmann
Challenger: Gary Kenton
Withdrawn: Andrew Belford

Because candidates had to withdraw their names from the ballot before the filing window closed on July 21, the five candidates who are out of their respective races will still be listed on the primary ballot.

Belford kept a low profile and said he entered the race so Hoffmann wouldn't run unopposed like she did two years ago. Under normal circumstances, it would be enough for me to endorse him but since Kenton is the more formidable candidate, I'll go with the latter.

Greensboro District 3

Incumbent: Justin Outling
Challengers: Antuan Marsh, Craig Martin
Withdrawn: Payton McGarry

Outling is a walking conflict of interest. His law firm does business with the city and the whole United Healthcare debacle stinks to high heaven. He might be the first black person to serve a majority white district in Greensboro but he can speak the language of the elites with the rest of them (after all, Irving Park does lie in this district).

While either one of the incumbent's remaining challengers would be a marked improvement, I have to give Martin the slight edge over Marsh. Martin seems to be the favorite from members of the creative community and Black Lives Matter activists.

Greensboro District 2

Seat holder: Goldie Wells
Challengers: C.J. Brinson, Jim Kee
Withdrawn: Felicia Angus, Tim Vincent

Jamal Fox resigned from his seat to move to Portland, OR with his girlfriend. He handpicked Vincent to replace him but the City Council opted to pick Wells (just like how City Council opted to appoint Justin Outling after Zack Matheny wanted former councilman Tom Phillips to replace him two years ago).

Wells is the third person in three election cycles to be appointed to her seat and then run for a full term. She represented District 2 from 2005 to 2009.

Wells's successor, Jim Kee, served two terms of his own before losing to Fox in 2013. The main reason to not support Kee's return other than the fact that he's been in office before is the fact that he's backed by developer interests like ex-mayor Robbie Perkins--hence, Kee's beholden to at least one of the city's political clans.

Both Wells and Kee had their chances and it's clearly time for a new generation to represent East Greensboro--Northeast Greensboro in particular. Fox should have been that person but he eventually got pulled in by the Marty Kotis and Roy Carroll factions.

Brinson is that person to represent East Greensboro because he gets it. He gets who Revolution Mill really caters to. I have seen some of my creative friends hold events there but most of them and the people who attended such events in the past aren't of the same skin color as me. As much as I enjoyed said events, East Greensboro residents are not the ones who are benefiting from the mill, it's the old money Irving Park crowd who once upon a time let Downtown Greensboro rot until the creative class helped revive it.

Greensboro 2025 Postmortem

The word that I'll use is cautious because I didn't see that coming. The City Council will shift from progressives being shut out to...